« hybrids! (genre 22.2/25) | Main | do as we do (authorship 15.3/25) »
December 17, 2005
put up or shut up (genre 22.3/25)
Bloom, Lynn Z. "Why Don't We Write What We Teach? And Publish it?" Journal of Advanced Composition 10:1 (1990): 87-100.
1 sentence (extracted) summary: "it is particularly important that teachers of advanced composition write and publish literary nonfiction" for the following simple reason: "if we don't practice what we preach and teach what we practice, what credibility, what authority can we claim?"
passages
90. gass on academic publishing: "articles are to be worn; they make up one's dossier the way uniforms make up a wardrobe, and it is not known—nor is it clear about uniforms either—whether the article has ever contained anything of lasting value"
91. "if we think like writers, we will teach like writers rather than as critics"; demonstrations of dillard's essay-writing and critic mary jane dickerson showing that those who do it don't talk about it in the ways teachers/critics do.
94. & publishing essays—even if they do do it, doesn't get them read by one's colleagues—bloom says "but i'd like to talk to my fellow teachers. i'd like to be able to pick up the journal of advanced composition or college composition and communication or rhetoric review and find in them belletristic essay of the kind that we talk about in class and use as exemplary models"—which would "validate this kind of writing as no other sort of acknowledgement could do"
96. she recounts a story of a student writer reading aloud an essay that he couldn't finish without crying, & finishes with "the rest of the class waited in respectful silence until our colleague had regained his composure" (she doesn't draw attention to it in any way, but she writes of her (graduate) student, who is also a writer as she is a writer, as a colleague)
Posted by ttobryan at December 17, 2005 12:53 AM